Online Shiurim

Blog

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim Maseches Makkos – Daf 11B: Mishna Nigmar Dino And Gemara Mai Taima (09/02/2013)

Review 11b משנה and גמרא until first set of two dots.
Continue the Gemara until “Nigmar Dino – six lines from bottom of the Amud
Questions;
  • Why does one who kills a Kohen Godal, or a Kohen Godal that accidently kills another men not punished with Galus? (Ritva)
  • Why is the Rotzaich not allowed to leave even if he is needed to save lives, but Pikuach Nefashos overrides all commandments of the Torah except for the three cardinal sins? (Bartunura, Tiferes Yisroel on the Mishna)
The גמרא concludes the death of the כ”ג, and not גלות, is what gives the רוצח a כפרה.

Learn תוס מידי which asks how do we reconcile our גמרא  with the גמרא ב that clearly says גלות is a כפרה?
  • In conclusion what is מכפרא according to answer of תוס? Ritva, Aruch LNer

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos – Daf 11A: Gemara Amar Rav Yehuda Amar Rav

Review . גמרא יא nine lines from the bottom עמוד until : משנה י”א

Questions:
  •  Everyone was going to  drown if דוד המלך did not put this piece of pottery with Hashem’s name back in place at the risk of erasing Hashem’s name. Why did דוד המלך need the ק”ו of אחיתופל, it should be obvious that it is permitted since peoples lives were at stake?

 

  • Why does the קללה of a חכם come true if it was not for a valid cause?
  •  Why does the קללה על תנאי  of a חכם come true even when the condition is fulfilled?
  •  How does the admission of ראובן annul the נידוי of יהודה?

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos – Daf 11A: Gemara Lifikach Imoseihen Shel Kohanim

Review quickly גמרא יא  after the משנה
until the bottom of the עמוד.

 [ ( ) means – see only after learnt all the גמרא assigned]
Questions;
  • Why does the כ”ג deserve to die for not praying for his generation? מהרש”א
  • How does the תפלה of the כ”ג help prevent others from sinning? See מכתב מאליהו ח”ג page 86)
  • Why does the death of the כ”ג free the רוצח from the עיר מקלט? (See מכתב מאליהו ח”ג page 87)
  • Everyone was going to  drown if דוד המלך did not put this piece of pottery with Hashem’s name back in place at the risk of erasing Hashem’s name. Why did דוד המלך need the ק”ו of אחיתופל, it should be obvious that it is permitted since peoples lives were at stake? (See ערוך לנר)
Learn גמרא י”א עמוד ב until the משנה
Question;
How does the admission of ראובן annul the נידוי of יהודה? (See ערוך לנר)

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos – Daf 11A: Gemara Sefer Shetafru BiPishtan And Mishna Echad Mashuach (08/4/2013)

Review very quickly גמרא יא. ” ספר שתפרו until משנה
Learn משנה and גמרא until the bottom of the עמוד.
[ ( ) means – see only after learnt all the גמרא assigned]
Questions;
  • Why doesn’t the כ”ג or his wife provide the food for the רוצחים? (See בן יהוידע, ערוך לנר)
  • Why does the כ”ג deserve to die for not praying for his generation? מהרש”א
  • How does the תפלה of the כ”ג help prevent others from sinning?
  • Why does the death of the כ”ג free the רוצח from the עיר מקלט? (See מכתב מאליהו ח”ג page 86)
  • Everyone was going to  drown if דוד המלך did not put this piece of pottery with Hashem’s name back in place at the risk of erasing Hashem’s name. Why did דוד המלך need the ק”ו of אחיתופל, it should be obvious that it is permitted since peoples lives were at stake? (See ערוך לנר)

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos Daf 10B: Tnan Mosrin Lo (08/05/2013)

Learn גמרא י’ עמוד ב  אמר מר (sixteen lines before the wide lines) until end of the עמוד

Questions;
  • If the גואל הדם is not allowed to kill the רוצח before he reaches the ערי מקלט why should the רוצח run to the ערי מקלט in the first place? Let him just sit on his couch in his own home?
  • Does the רוצח have permission to turn around and kill the גואל הדם who is chasing after him? משנה למלך ה’ רוצח א,ט”ו
Bring a proof from the גמרא that the ת”ח are assigned before ב”ד determined the killing was accidental.
Bring a proof from the גמרא that the ת”ח are assigned after ב”ד determined the killing was accidental.

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos – Daf 10B: Amar Rav Huna (07/31/2013)

Review quickly גמרא י: אמר רב הונא  (sixth medium line) until אמר ר אלעזר (eight lines before the wide lines.)

Questions;
  • In the משנה דף י”א עמוד ב there’s a מחלוקת whether the גואל הדם has a מצוה or just a רשות to kill the רוצח. How could רב הונא argue on the משנה?
  • The רבנן argue on רב הונא and hold that the גואל הדם is חייב מיתה for killing the רוצח. How could they argue on the משנה? Very important ה’ ב”ח אות ב

Important point to clarify: Is the מחלוקת before ב”ד sentenced the רוצח to גלות or after?  Bring a proof from the גמרא

  • If the מחלוקת is before ב”ד sentenced the רוצח to גלות how could the גואל הדם kill the רוצח maybe the murder was a total freak accident and the רוצח is not even חייב גלות?
  • If the מחלוקת is after ב”ד sentenced the רוצח to גלות how could רב הונא hold the גואל הדם is פטור if he kills the רוצח. Don’t we have to give the רוצח the opportunity to run to גלות?
Important point to clarify: When are the two ת”ח assigned to the רוצח immediately after the murder or after the רוצח was sentenced to גלות? See רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ה,ח, מאירי
  • If the two ת”ח are assigned immediately after the murder how could they tell the גואל הדם that the רוצח only killed בשוגג maybe he killed intentionally?

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos: Daf 10A – Amar Rabba Bar Rav Huna (07/29/2013)

Learn גמרא י: אמר רבה  (first medium line) until אמר ר אלעזר (eight lines before the wide lines.)

Questions;
  • Why does רב הונא need a proof from תורה, נבאים & כתובים? See ערוך לנר
  • If the two ת”ח are assigned immediately after the murder how could they tell the גואל הדם that the רוצח only killed בשוגג? See רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ה,ח