Online Shiurim

Blog

Gemara / Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 17B: Gemara Amar Rava… (05/21/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”2505″]

Download Here

Learn  גמרא יז: “אמר רבא (second line from top of the עמוד)
Until “וכי מזהירין ” (six lines before the bottom of the עמוד )

Questions:
  • The רבנן ask on ר”ש that חטאת & אשם should be considered more חמור then עולה since they are מכפרין as opposed to an עולה. But this is not true! An עולה is also מכפר?
  • What are the two אכילות?
  • The רבנן say that everything is more חמור then עולה because everything else is eaten.  This contradicts what the רבנן just said a line prior! They said עולה is more חמור then חטאת & אשם because it’s not eaten rather it’s entirely consumed? (Learn ריטב”א )

Gemara / Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 17A: Mishna HaOchel Bikurim (05/14/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”2479″]

Download Here

Learn .משנה יז and the גמרא until the bottom of the Amud
(We will be covering ground tonight)
On Sugya before the משנה
Learn “רש” י חולין קב: “טמאה
Questions:
  • How does רש” י  define בריה  different then  “תוס’ “ורבנן ?
  • What is the Machlokes between רש” י and  תוס’ dependent on?
  • According to ר”ש why is a חיוב מלקות on eating a כל שהוא, yet for a חיוב קרבן one needs to eat a כזית?  Learn ריטב” א

Gemara / Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 17A: ViHacha BiHa Kamifligi… (05/12/2-014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”2466″]

Download Here

Quickly review “גמרא יז. “והכא בהא קא מיפלגי  until the two dots.
Question:
  • What was the big effort to designate מעשר עני, all that one needs to do is to designate a certain segment of the produce without separating it from the rest? learn ה’ הגר”א
Learn .גמרא יז from the two dots until the משנה.
Questions:
  • In conclusion what is considered a בריה ?
  • Why does the רבנן agree that one is חייב מלקות for eating a בריה even when it is less then a כזית ?
Learn “תוס’ “ורבנן who gives new guidelines for what is considers a בריה  according to the רבנן
  • How does ‘תוס new guidelines fit with the words of ורבנן בריית נשמה חשובה ?
Learn רש” י חולין קב: “טמאה
  • What is the reason that a בריה is not בטל in a mixture?
  • According to ר”ש why is a חיוב מלקות on eating a כל שהוא yet for a חיוב קרבן one needs to eat a כזית?  Learn ריטב” א

Gemara / Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 16B to 17A: Sugya of Teruma Shiur 2 (05/07/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”2447″]

Download Here

Review the ”   גמרא טז: “אמר רב יוסף כתנאי until the two dots on .יז

Questions:
  • The גמרא explains that if there is no איסור טבל for מעשר עני then there is no obligation to separate מספק, Why not? even if there is no Malkus  there is definitely a Mitzvah to separate the מעשר עני?
  • Why was an עם הארץ careful on איסור טבל and not for איסור גזל ?
  • If they were concerned for חיוב מיתה Why did they not separate תרומת מעשר?
  • What was the big effort to designate מעשר עני, all that one needs to do is to designate a certain segment of the produce without separating it from the rest? learn ה’ הגר”א and look up גמרא נדרים פד ?