Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 19A: U’Mai Kasavar… (07/16/2014)
[jwplayer mediaid=”2844″]
Very quickly review “גמרא י”ט. “ומאי קסבר (twelve lines from bottom of the עמוד ) until “וכי דבר” (second to last line in the עמוד )
Continue the גמרא until two dots on : יט
Learn “תוס’ “ואי who asks a few questions on רש”י (starting from ” אבל קשה ” -last line of the narrow lines- until “ועוד קשה ” )
Continue the גמרא until two dots on : יט
Learn “תוס’ “ואי who asks a few questions on רש”י (starting from ” אבל קשה ” -last line of the narrow lines- until “ועוד קשה ” )
Questions:
From ‘תוס questions on רש”י it is clear that תוס’ understands that if the בהמ”ק is not קדשה for all times then its obvious that it is forbidden to eat מעשר שני in ירושלים.
- Why? What is the connection?
- How does רש”י deflect these questions?
Continue learning ‘תוס from “לכך צריך לומר דגריס” until “ואם תאמר”
Questions:
- What is the key issue of whether or not מעשר שני is required to be brought and eaten in ירושלים in our times even though we do not have a בית המקדש according to רש”י and according to ‘תוס?
- What is the conclusion of the גמרא in regards to קדושת א”י , קדושת בהמ”ק ,קדושת ירושלים ? according to רש”י and according to ‘תוס ?