Rabbi Gershon West: Brachos 45A: Gemara Mina Hani Mili… (09/11/2014)
[jwplayer mediaid=”3289″]
Mareh Mekomos
Begin on 45a at the beginning of the gemara and learn until the two dots at the last narrow line. See Rashi and tosfos dh bekolo. Is zimun min hatorah or miderbanan? See Ritva here dh deksiv and Meiri dh veinyan zimun. When the gemara asks mena hani mili about zimun, which aspect of zimun is it asking about? See Rashi dhmena hani mili with Pnei Yehoshua on the Rashi. On the gemara that learns out of Moshe that a metargem may not raise his voice above the Rav, what is the proof from the passuk? See tosfos dh bekolo and see Mahrsha on tosfos and in Chidushei Agados. See the shidush of the Rambam in this din in hilchos talmud torah perek 4 halacha 3. The gemara appears to contradict the Rambam? Regarding the question that we spoke about, what should one with regards to zimun if he wants to leave a chasunah early, Igros Moshe (Orach Chaim siman 56) discusses this.
