Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 9B: Mishna HaSuma Ainoh Goleh And Gemara (06/26/2013)
Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 9B: Mishna HaSuma Ainoh Goleh And Gemara
Learn the first משנה ט עמוד ב and the גמרא until the end of the third wide line.
Questions;
- Why is a סומא exempt from גלות? See רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ו,יד
- If רבי יהודה is using “בבלי דעת” to exclude מתכוין then it is still a מיעוט אחר מיעוט which should include a סומא for going to גלות?
Major question: There are two elements to the concept that a person needs התראה .
- 1. To determine the crime was committed intentionally. 2. To warn the person of the punishment he is culpable for committing this crime. How could ר’ יוסי hold the שונא is חייב מיתה even though we take for granted he murdered intentionally but who says the שונא knows the severity of the punishment for murder? ריטב”א ו: ” דתניא
Point to ponder:
- Does the תנא קמא disagree with ר’ שמעון? and if so why? ערוך לנר, רש”ש, תוס’ ב. “מעידין” .. אבל קשה
