Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 18B: Gemara Amar Rav Elazar Amar Rav Hoshiya… (06/18/2014)
[jwplayer mediaid=”2633″]
Introduction to next סוגיא:
1. Learn the פסוקים of דברים פרק כו פסוק ד’-י’
2. The ביכורים are brought to the Beis Hamikdash during the time period up to and including סוכות. From סוכות until חנוכה one is still required to bring the ביכורים but can not do קרייה – recite the פסוקים of “…. ארמי אובד “
2. The ביכורים are brought to the Beis Hamikdash during the time period up to and including סוכות. From סוכות until חנוכה one is still required to bring the ביכורים but can not do קרייה – recite the פסוקים of “…. ארמי אובד “
Learn the :גמרא יח from “אמר ר’ אלעזר ” (middle of the עמוד) until “מאי ר’ יהודה (four lines before the wide lines)
Question:
- What is the contradiction in ר’ יהודה regarding the necessity of הנחה and קריאה?
- Why can we not answer that when ר’ יהודה said הנחה is essential that’s is in regard to בדיעבד, but when ר’ יהודה said ביכורים are permitted only after קריאה that is in regards of what to do לכתחילה?
Continue learning the גמרא until רבא בר אדא (last line of the עמוד )
