Blog

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Monday Night Gemara Shiur Bava Metzia 21A to 21B Amar Leiy Hahu MiDiRabanan… (07/30/2012)

Learn Gemara 31a “Amar lei …” (5 lines into the big wide lines) until 31b “Hashev Tashiv” (10th line from top of Amud)
Questions; The Gemara says on bottom of 31a that one has to help load & unload someone else’s animal because the animal is in pain. Contradiction to Gemara a few lines before that says there is no “Tzar Baalei Chaim” if one refuses to help load someone else’s animal? Ritva 31a “Aval”
The Gemara on top of 31b says a person is only required to help load & unload someone else’s animal if the owner is there. Contradiction to the Gemara 31a which learnt from the double language of the Pasuk that one is required to help load & unload even if the owner is not there? Tofos 31b “Aval”

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Monday Night Gemara Shiur Bava Metzia 31A: Amar Lei Rava Eeh Yagid Olov Reioh (07/23/2012)

Learn Gemara 31a “Amar lei Rava ..”(first medium size line) until second set of two dots
Question; When one removes a cow that is grazing in a vineyard of a Jew to prevent the animal from damaging the vineyard is he now obligated to return the cow or not? Ritva “Ha”, Rosh siman 22
Continue Gemara from the 2 dots until first word on 7th wide line.
Question; why would we think that if one needs the mother bird for a mitzvah that would over ride the mitzvah of shiloach hakan? Ritva “Ein”, Tosfos Rosh “Ldvar”

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Wednesday Night Gemara Shiur Bava Metzia 30A: Raah Mayim She Shotfin (07/18/2012)

Learn Gemara 31a “Raah ..”(end of 4th line from the top) until second set of two dots
Questions;  What is the conclusion of the gemara in regards to Hashovas aveida on land? Ritva “Mahu”
When one removes a cow that is grazing in a vineyard of a Jew to prevent the animal from damaging the vineyard is he now obligated to return the cow or not? Ritva “Ha”, Rosh siman 22
Point to ponder; According to Rava when the torah includes Hoshavas aveida on land is that just for the prohibition of “Lo suchal Lihisalem” or also for the Mitzva of ” Hashev Teshivim”?

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Monday Night Gemara Shiur Bava Metzia 30B to 31A: Mishna Aizo Hee Aveida and Gemara Utoo

We will be be”H be covering alot of ground this week.
Learn Mishna 30b & Gemara until two dots on 31a.  Learn Last 3 lines of Tosfos 25b “V’im” & first half of the Rosh on Mishna 25b “Matza”
Questions; when Braisa 31a says if something is placed for 3 days one can assume its lost does that apply to items placed near a fence as well?  See First Rashba 31a.  What is the conclusion of the gemara in regards to Hashovas aveida on land? Ritva “Mahu”
Point to ponder; According to Rava when the torah includes Hoshavas aveida on land is that just for the prohibition of “Lo suchal Lihisalem” or also for the Mitzva of ” Hashev Teshiveim”?