Author: admin

Rabbi Gershon West: Brachos 47B: Achal Tevel UMaazer ViChulei: Tevel Pshita… (11/13/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”3788″]

Download Here

Begin on 47b, at the two dots on the second middle size line. Learn until the third line from bottom, amar Rav Yochanan. See tosfos dh mitzvah. The gemara says that a katan can be mitztaref to a mezuman in certain cases. How can a katan that cannot talk (mutal bearisah) be part of a mezuman? Perhaps in the meiri on the previous gemara that we saw there is an answer to this question. The gemara says that one can free a slave and trangress an asay for a “mitzvah derabbim”. What is the mitzvah derabbim here in the gemara? See tosfos dh mitzvah and Rosh siman 20 beginning from tanu rabanan until a few lines later velays hilchasah that discusses this point. On tosfos dh mitzvah, see Mahrsha that asks a question on tosfos. See Tzlach dh tosfos dh mitzvah in the first paragraph that answers the question. On the gemara that one who is in the first ten of a minyan receives the same schar as all those who come later, why is this so? See Mahrsha dh leolam.

Brachos47B

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 21B: Aisevei Abaye… (11/12/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”3779″]

Download Here

Learn :גמרא כא from “איתביה אביי ” (end of the first wide line) until the first set of two dots on . דף כב
Learn “ריטב”א כא: “אמר רבא explains the case of אין חילוק מלאכות ביו” ט
Learn “ערוך לנר כב. “משום הבערה

Question:
  • Why does the  גמרא not ask to add on מלקות for working land on שביעית ? Learn “ריטב”א כא: “ולילקי

Makkos21B

Rabbi Gershon West: Brachos 47B: Maaser Sheini ViHekdish Shenifdu: Pshita Hucha Bimai Askinan… (11/11/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”3770″]

Download Here

Begin on 47b, at the two dots on the second line, maaser sheini. Learn until the fifth wide line, veamar Rav Yehoshua. See tosfos dh amar Rav Huna. See Rosh siman 20 from the beginning of the piece until tanu Rabanan maaseh that discusses being mezaman with a am haaretz. See Meiri dh am haaretz gamur. See Shulchan Aruch siman 199 sif 3 with Mishna Brurah with Biur Halacha that discusses whether ine may be mezamen with someone that does aveiros.

Brachos47B

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 21B: Amar Lei Ulla LiRav Nachman… (11/10/2014

[jwplayer mediaid=”3750″]

Download Here

Learn :גמרא כא from “אמר ליה עולא ” (four lines before the wide lines) until דף כב. “א”ל  (end of seventh line)

Questions:
  • Why does the  גמרא not ask to add on מלקות for working land on שביעית ? See ריטב”א
  • Why does the  גמרא not ask to add on מלקות for violating יום כיפור ? See שאגת אריה
  • How could “רש”י “ואין חילוק say case is one violated two or three melochos בהעלם אחד .  Big problem: העלמה is used in context for culpability of a קרבן  , but there is no קרבן for violating יום טוב ?

Makkos21B

Rabbi Gershon West: Brachos 47A: Rav U’Shmuel Havi Yusvee BiSudusa… (11/06/2014)

[jwplayer mediaid=”3711″]

Download Here

Begin on 47a, rav uShmuel haveh, 24 lines from the bottom of the amud. Learn until 47b, at the two dots achal tevel, on the second mid size line. See tosfos dh ilu, dh hilchasa and dh amar Rav Huna on amud beis. On the first gemara that discusses making a zimun with someone that joins at the very end, is this a chiyuv or voluntary? See Rabeinu Yonah at the beginning of the very first piece in the perek that brings a machlokes.  On the gemara that discusses not making a zimun with a am haretz, see Rosh at the beginning of siman 20. See Meiri on 47b dh am haretz gamur (on page 89). See the halacha in Mishnah Brurah siman 199 sif 3 with Mishnah Brurah and Biur Halacha dh am haretz.

brachos47A