Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Gemara Brachos – Keitzad Mevarchin: Night Seder Chabura, Wednesday night – Cheshvan 18, Daf 35a (10/28/26)
Continue learning גמרא דף לה “אשכחן כרם until the two dots.
Write out a list of the different sources for Bracha Rishona
On Monday night we learnt “תוס’ דף לה. “לפניו לכ״ש and “תוס’ סוכה דף כו: “ולא בירך אחריו and רא”ש ברכות פרק ו’ ס’ טז brought three proofs that the ק”ו is not absolute and does not obligated a Bracha Rishona M’Doraaisa.
Questions:
Why is the logic of the קל וחומר not binding?
See רא”ש ברכות פרק ו’ ס’ טז
https://hebrewbooks.org/
Is the סברא of אסור ליהנות מעולם הזה בלי ברכה an obligation from the Torah or from the Rabanan?
Learn תוס’ “אלא סברא
In conclusion is a Bracha Rishona an obligation from the Torah or from the Rabanan?
Learn ר”ח (on the side of the Gemara)
and תוס’ רא”ש
Learn לחם משנה על הרמב”ם ה’ ברכות ב:יד
Learn פני יהושע & צל”ח
https://hebrewbooks.org/
According to the פני יהושע who says that Bracha Rishona is M’Doraaisa in some instances how does he explain why a בעל קרי and a פועל may not recite a Bracha Rishona?
