Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Gemara Eruvin: First Perek, יום רביעי Tamuz 23, Daf 12a-12b (07/12/23)

Click on Right Side of Player to Download

Learn the “גמרא דף יב. “רב יוסף (fifth line of the medium sized lines) until the two dots on top of דף יב עמוד ב

Question:

Why does a Chatzer require a different and more stringent תיקון than a Mavui to permit one to carry inside the Chatzer?

Learn שו”ת רשב”א חלק ה ס’ רג

https://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=65894&st=&pgnum=92

Learn “תוס’ “בפסי

Learn מהרש”א

https://hebrewbooks.org/pdfpager.aspx?req=14312&st=&pgnum=266

The Gemara concludes in the case חצר נפרצה לים it is prohibited to draw from the water but permitted to carry inside the Chatzer as long as there are גידודי. Rashi explains גידודי is a wall under the water. 

Major Question

If the wall that is being covered by the water is good enough to allow one to carry  inside the Chatzer why does it not also allow one to draw from the water?

Learn תוס’ דף יב: “הכא