Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 17B: Gemara Amar Rava… (05/21/2014)
[jwplayer mediaid=”2505″]
Learn גמרא יז: “אמר רבא (second line from top of the עמוד)
Until “וכי מזהירין ” (six lines before the bottom of the עמוד )
Questions:
- The רבנן ask on ר”ש that חטאת & אשם should be considered more חמור then עולה since they are מכפרין as opposed to an עולה. But this is not true! An עולה is also מכפר?
- What are the two אכילות?
- The רבנן say that everything is more חמור then עולה because everything else is eaten. This contradicts what the רבנן just said a line prior! They said עולה is more חמור then חטאת & אשם because it’s not eaten rather it’s entirely consumed? (Learn ריטב”א )
