Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 13B: Mai Taima D’Rabi Yishmael (12/25/2013)
[jwplayer mediaid=”1841″]
Quickly review י”ג עמוד ב from מ”ט דר’ ישמעאל until ור’ עקיבא מאי טעמא (half way down the narrow lines)
Questions:
- The גמרא asks what’s the reason one receives מלקות according to ר’ ישמעאל. Why does the גמרא ask this only on ר’ ישמעאל?
- Where is the source of מלקות for violating a לאו according to the other opinions?
- How does ר”ע & ר’ יצחק explain the פסוק of והפלה ? See ריטב”א אי
Continue learning the גמרא until רבא אמר (first wide line)
Question:
- The גמרא asks מ”ט דר”ע. What is the question of the גמרא? In the ברייתא we quoted above ר”ע says his reason? Learn תוס’ ור”ע
- What is the point of disagreement between ר”ע and ר’ ישמעאל?
Point to ponder:
- How is מיתה with מלקות a מיתה אריכתא?
