Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim Maseches Makkos – Daf 11B: Mishna Nigmar Dino And Gemara Mai Taima (09/02/2013)
Review 11b משנה and גמרא until first set of two dots.
Continue the Gemara until “Nigmar Dino – six lines from bottom of the Amud
Continue the Gemara until “Nigmar Dino – six lines from bottom of the Amud
Questions;
- Why does one who kills a Kohen Godal, or a Kohen Godal that accidently kills another men not punished with Galus? (Ritva)
- Why is the Rotzaich not allowed to leave even if he is needed to save lives, but Pikuach Nefashos overrides all commandments of the Torah except for the three cardinal sins? (Bartunura, Tiferes Yisroel on the Mishna)
The גמרא concludes the death of the כ”ג, and not גלות, is what gives the רוצח a כפרה.
Learn תוס מידי which asks how do we reconcile our גמרא with the גמרא ב that clearly says גלות is a כפרה?
- In conclusion what is מכפרא according to answer of תוס? Ritva, Aruch LNer
