Monthly Archive: November 2013

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 13A: Conclusion of the Second Perek (11/18/2013)

[jwplayer mediaid=”1664″]

Download Here

סוגיא: חוזר לשררה
Quickly review the .גמרא יג from second set of two dots until end of the
פרק
Points to ponder:
  • Last week we pointed out the מחלוקת between תוס & the ריטב”א whether the גזירה שוה of שיבה שיבה from עבד עברי to רוצח is needed just for the דין of ר”מ or also for the דין of ר”י as well.  What is their point of disagreement?
  • Can a רוצח be appointed to a new position after he is set free from גלות?
  • Does ר”מ & ר”י also argue regarding a person who commits a different crime other then murder. For example theft or idolatry?
  • If a person of stature commits an Aveirah, does he get dismissed from his position?  If he does Teshuva can he get reinstated?  Learn ריטבא

The next two weeks will be designated for a review of the entire second perek.

A person who learns תורה and does not review is comparable to someone who plants and does not harvest. (ילקוט שמעוני יהושוע א,ו)
Our learning is the planting, our reviewing is the harvesting – the real enjoyment for all our toil.
הצלחה רבה

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 13A: Does a murderer go back to his family postion or not

[jwplayer mediaid=”1651″]

Download Here

Learn the.גמרא יג from first set of two dots until end of the .פרק
Learn רש”י very carefully as well as תוס’ גמר

Major question:
  • According to רש”י is the מחלוקת of ר”י and ר”מ based on how to learn the words of וכן בגולה or on whether they learn the גזירה שוה of שיבה שיבה? Learn ריטבא
Point to ponder:
  • If a person of stature commits an Aveirah does he get dismissed from his position?  If he does Teshuva can he get reinstated?  Learn ריטבא

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 13A: The differences between the 6 ערי מקלט and the 42 ערי לויה. & חזרה לשררה Gemara (11/11/2013)

[jwplayer mediaid=”1642″]

Download Here

Tonight’s סוגיא: The differences between the 6 ערי מקלט and the 42 ערי לויה.  & חזרה לשררה

Quickly review .גמרא יג until first set of two dots.
Question’s:
  • Why does רש”י mean that the city has to pay for the rent of the רוצח, and not the רוצח himself?
  • According to תוס explanation of ר”י does the רוצח have to pay the rent?
  • What are the other differences in הלכה between the 6 ערי מקלט and the 42 ערי לויה?
  • Point to ponder: Why are they different?

Learn the גמרא until end of the .פרק
Learn רש”י וכן בגולה very carefully, תוס’ גמר

Major question:
According to רש”י is the מחלוקת of ר”י and ר”מ based on how to learn the words of וכן בגולה or on whether they learn the גזירה שוה of שיבה שיבה? Learn ריטבא