Online Shiurim

Monthly Archive: July 2013

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos – Daf 10B: Amar Rav Huna (07/31/2013)

Review quickly גמרא י: אמר רב הונא  (sixth medium line) until אמר ר אלעזר (eight lines before the wide lines.)

Questions;
  • In the משנה דף י”א עמוד ב there’s a מחלוקת whether the גואל הדם has a מצוה or just a רשות to kill the רוצח. How could רב הונא argue on the משנה?
  • The רבנן argue on רב הונא and hold that the גואל הדם is חייב מיתה for killing the רוצח. How could they argue on the משנה? Very important ה’ ב”ח אות ב

Important point to clarify: Is the מחלוקת before ב”ד sentenced the רוצח to גלות or after?  Bring a proof from the גמרא

  • If the מחלוקת is before ב”ד sentenced the רוצח to גלות how could the גואל הדם kill the רוצח maybe the murder was a total freak accident and the רוצח is not even חייב גלות?
  • If the מחלוקת is after ב”ד sentenced the רוצח to גלות how could רב הונא hold the גואל הדם is פטור if he kills the רוצח. Don’t we have to give the רוצח the opportunity to run to גלות?
Important point to clarify: When are the two ת”ח assigned to the רוצח immediately after the murder or after the רוצח was sentenced to גלות? See רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ה,ח, מאירי
  • If the two ת”ח are assigned immediately after the murder how could they tell the גואל הדם that the רוצח only killed בשוגג maybe he killed intentionally?

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos: Daf 10A – Amar Rabba Bar Rav Huna (07/29/2013)

Learn גמרא י: אמר רבה  (first medium line) until אמר ר אלעזר (eight lines before the wide lines.)

Questions;
  • Why does רב הונא need a proof from תורה, נבאים & כתובים? See ערוך לנר
  • If the two ת”ח are assigned immediately after the murder how could they tell the גואל הדם that the רוצח only killed בשוגג? See רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ה,ח

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos Daf 10A To 10B: Amar Rav Yehoshua Ben Levi (07/24/2013)

Learn גמרא י. אמר ר’ יהושע בן לוי six lines from bottom of the עמוד until  דף י: אמר רב הונא six lines into the medium size lines

Questions;
  • How could people be so cruel and crude to wish for the death of Dovid Hamelech? מהרש”א
  • The גמרא says the person who killed בשוגג was deserving to be exiled because he had killed someone בשוגג at an earlier date without witnesses. Based on this reasoning how was it possible for him to kill someone בשוגג initially? See מהרש”א
  • Why does רב הונא need a proof from תורה, נבאים & כתובים? See מהרש”א

Uncategorized

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Maseches Makkos Daf 10A: Tanna Talmid SheGulah (07/17/2013)

Learn “… גמרא י. “תנא in middle of the sixth wide line until “א”ר יהושוע seven lines from bottom of the Amud.

Questions;
  • Why do we need to send the רבי of the רוצח  to גלות, can’t we just have a great תלמיד חכם in גלות that would teach him תורה? Important ריטב”א “מגלין
  • Why is a persons רבי considered the livelihood of the רוצח ? Very important  רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ז,א
  • If a רבי is sent to גלות the ישיבה is sent along with him.  Is this true as well when the רבי has to go to גלות because his תלמיד was sent to גלות? See ערוך לנר “מגלין
  • The אמוראים give many different explanations on the words ומי אוהב בהמון לא תבואה.  How could they all interpret the פסוק to mean לו תבואה – to HIM their is produce when clearly the פסוק says לא תבואה – there is NOT produce? מהרש”א

 

Makkos / Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim Maseches Makkos – Daf 10A – ViKadeish (07/10/2013)

Learn גמרא י. וקדש four lines before the wide lines until א”ר תנחום in middle of the wide lines.

Questions:
  • Is the ברייתא discussing the ערי מקלט or the ערי לויה ?
  • If the population of the ערי מקלט decreased the ברייתא says we need to import כהנים, לוים, וישראלים. Whats the need for these three classifications of people? ריטב”א , ערוך לנר
  • Why do we need to send the רבי of the רוצח  to גלות, can’t we just have a great תלמיד חכם in גלות that would teach him תורה? Important ריטב”א “מגלין
  • Why is a persons רבי considered the רוצח livelihood? Very important  רמב”ם ה’ רוצח ז,א
  • If a רבי is sent to גלות the ישיבה is sent along with him.  Is this true as well when the רבי has to go to גלות because his תלמיד was sent to גלות? See ערוך לנר “מגלין