Online Shiurim

Monthly Archive: June 2012

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Monday Night Gemara Shiur Bava Metzia 30A LiTzorchu LiTzorcho Mai Part 2 (06/25/2012)

 Learn Gemara 30A from last 2 dots “Matza Sak … until last line of Amud. Major point; When does the mitzvah of Hashev Tishivaim start? Rashi “Hai” says it starts on sight, Question on Rashi the Gem 26B “Himtin ad Shnisyashu … is clear the Mitzvah Aseh does not start on  sight? Learn Nemukei Yosef “Aseh” (on our Gemara 30A). Ramban  says the mitzvah starts when one picks up the Aveida. But our Gemara is explicit it starts on sight? Learn Ramban 30A on our Gemara
Our Gemara labels Hashavas Aveida as “Money”. Why is it not considered “Issur”?  Why do we not push off “Issur” thru “Money”?
 I will quickly read the Gemara from middle of Amud “Shani Hacha” until second set of 2 dots and discuss the following questions; What’s the Nafka Mina between Rashi & Tosfos “Ltzorcho” explanation of the question of “Mai Avidita Gabei”?
According to Tosfos what is the Gemara’s answer “the owner went overseas”?

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim's shiurim

 by 

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Wednesday Night Gemara Shiur Bava Metzia 30A Ta Shmu LiTzorcho ULitzorcha Mai.. (06/20/2012)

Let’s gets Pshat in the Gemara 

1) Review quickly 2 dots “Kli Kesef” until next 2 dots. Questions; What iathe Nafka Mina between Rashi & Tosfos “Ltzorcho” explanation of the question of “Mai Avidita Gabei”?
According to Tosfos what is the Gemara’s answer “the owner went overseas”?
2) Learn next gem from 2 dots until bottom of Amud. Major point; When does the mitzvah of Hasheiv Teshivaim start? Rashi “Hai” says it starts on sight, Question on Rashi the Gemara 26B last case of Rava “himtin ad Shnisyashu … Is clear the mitzvah Aseh does not start on sight? Nemukei Yosef on our Gemara. Ramban says the mitzvah starts when one picks up the Aveida. But our Gemara is explicit it starts on sight? Learn Ramban