Category: Makkos

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 22B: Mishna Over Aveira, Gemara ViHaTanya and Mishna Kama Malkin… (12/03/14)

Download Here

Very quickly review :גמרא כב from second set of two dots until the משנה.

Questions:

According to the ריב”ן

  • What is the חילק between being reevaluated on the same day as the first evaluation or on a later date?
  • Why does the נלקה not need to endure his full share of lashes if there was an underestimation in the original evaluation ?
  • Why does the נלקה not need to endure his full share of lashes when the reevaluation is done on a later date and its clear he can endure the full amount contrary to the original evaluation which said he can only endure part of the 39?

Continue learning the משנה and גמרא including the second משנה until the bottom of the עמוד

Point to ponder:
  • When the נלקה is evaluated that he can endure 42 lashes we consider it as getting 2 sets if lashes.
  • Is this only for one action that is a violation of 2 לאוין or even for 2 individual violations of 2 לאוין ?  See ערל”נ

Questions:

  • Why does the חזן  rip the shirt of the נלקה ? See ריטב”א
  • When the מלקה adds an extra lash resulting in the death of the נלקה the  מלקה go to גלות. Why? גלות. Is only for an accident? This is negligence? (See ריבן , ריטב”א )

Makkos22B

Rabbi Avraham Shulman: Makkos 21A: KiSavar Rabi Yosi Sreeta ViGreeda Achas Hee (12/01/14)

Download Here

Makkos21A

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 22B: Rabi Yehuda Omer Arbaim Shleimos…: Amar R’ Yitzchak Mai Taima DiRabi Yehuda… (12/01/14)

Download Here

Learn :גמרא כב from first set of two dots until  משנה.

Question:
According to the ריב”ן
  • What is the חילק between being reevaluated on the same day as the first evaluation or on a later date?
  • Why does the נלקה not need to endure his full share of lashes if there was an underestimation in the original evaluation ?
  • Why does the נלקה not need to endure his full share of lashes when the reevaluation is done on a later date and its clear he can endure the full amount contrary to the original evaluation which said he can only endure part of the 39?
Point to ponder:
  • According to רבי יהודה when the נלקה can only endure part of the 39 lashes would he still receive one or more lashes בין כתיפיו?
  • According to רבי יהודה when the נלקה can only endure 20 lashes, will he receive 2 lashes בין כתיפיו?  (The ערל”נ “דכתיב” and “אשר” discusses these two questions)

Continue learning the משנה and גמרא until the second משנה on the עמוד

Makkos22B

Rabbi Avraham Shulman: Makkos 20B to 21A: ViHamisareit Sreeta Achas ViChulai…: Tanu Rabanan ViSeret… (11/26/14)

Download Here

Makkos20B

Makkos21A

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 22B: Mai Taima Ee Ksiv Arbaim BiMispar… (11/26/14)

Download Here

Very quickly review .משנה כב and :גמרא כב until first set of two dots.

The ראשונים seem to give an entirely different reason then the גמרא
why we only give 39 lashes when the תורה says 40 (See ריטב”א , and רמב”ם ה’ סנהדרין י”ז,א )

Questions:

  • How can they give a different reason then the גמרא?
  • What is a נפקא מיניה between the explanations? (See “ערוך לנר “בצרו )
  • Why does רש”י דברים כ”ה,ג give a different explanation then the גמרא ?
Continue learning the גמרא until the next משנה
Question:
  • Our גמרא says a ת”ח is greater then a ס”ת. Learn “גמרא קידושין לג. “איבעיא  which seems to say just the opposite. ( ר” ן שם  and מהרש”א here in Makkos )

Makkos22B

Rabbi Avraham Shulman: Makkos 20B: ViHaMakif Pias Rosho: Tanu Rabanan Pias Rosho Sof Rosho… (11/24/14)

Download Here

Makkos20B

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 22A to 22B: Amar Rav Hoshiya… (11/24/14)

Download Here

Learn .גמרא כב  from “אמר רב הושעיא ” (three lines before the משנה) until the משנה

Question:
  • What is the כלאים in the case of שור פסולי מוקדשין ? (Three explanations ריב”ן “המרביע”, תוס’ ” שהרי”, ריטב”א “אמר )

Learn משנה and :גמרא כב  until first set of two dots.

The גמרא explains why we only give 39 lashes when the תורה says 40 from the way the תורה writes the order of the words in the פסוק.
Learn the ראשונים who seem to give an entirely different reason then the גמרא
See ריטב”א , and רמב”ם ה’ סנהדרין י”ז,א
Points to ponder:
  • How can they give a different reason then the גמרא?
  • What is a נפקא מיניה between the explanations?
– On previous גמרא:
The גמרא concludes משנה does not hold of איסור כולל .
  • So how could יו”ט be חל on שמיטה?
  • How could נזיר be חל on כהן?

Makkos22A

Makkos22B

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 22A: Amar Leih Rav Zeira LiRabi Manee ViLichshov Nami… (11/19/14)

Download Here

Learn .גמרא כב  from  אמר רבי זעירא ” (three lines before the wide lines ) until the משנה

Learn Rashi for introduction to  איסור כולל and  איסור מוסיף.

Learn תוס’ “מנהיג

Question:
  • Why did the גמרא ask from שבועה now after we already realized the משנה did not mention every option of לאו?
  • The גמרא concludes משנה does not hold of איסור כולל . So how could יו”ט be חל on שמיטה?
  • How could נזיר be חל on כהן?

Makkos22A

Rabbi Avraham Shulman: Makkos 20A to 20B: Hanee Daled ViHay Krichos… (11/17/14)

Download Here

Makkos20A

Makkos20B

Rabbi Baruch Bodenheim: Makkos 22A: ViHuTunee Rabi Chiya Lokeh Shtayim Al Acheeluso… (11/17/14)

Download Here

Learn .גמרא כב  from the two dots until “אמר רב הושעיא ” (three lines before the משנה)
Learn “ריטב”א כב. “וליחשוב who explains how these violations are committed at the same time of plowing

Question:

The גמרא lists many additional לאוין that one could violate while plowing.  How does the גמרא answer why they are not included in the list of the משנה?  Learn “תוס’ ” מתקיף

Makkos22A